The child heard a coordinated sentence and wondered: On children’s difficulty in understanding coordination and relative clauses with crossing dependencies
نویسندگان
چکیده
Children are known to have problems in understanding Wh-movement constructions in which the object moves across an overt subject (as is the case in object-relatives, Wh-object questions, and topicalization). To test whether crossing dependencies are also problematic when no Wh-movement is involved and whether dependencies in which the subject crosses an object are also difficult, we test a construction that has not been studied before, a coordination sentence like The girl kissed the boy and went to the beach. This structure includes a dependency – between the empty subject of went to the beach and the girl. This dependency crosses the object the boy. We tested the comprehension of this construction in comparison with coordination that does not involve a dependency, and with coordination that includes a dependency without intervention. We also compared it with relative clauses with and without intervention, object-relatives and subject-relatives, respectively. We ran five experiments to assess the comprehension of these structures and the correlation between them. Experiments 1 and 2 tested sentence-picture matching in 49 3;4 to 5;5 year old Hebrewand European-Portuguese-speaking children; Experiments 3 and 4 used comprehension questions in 41 3;6 to 5;6 year old Hebrewand European-Portuguesespeaking children. Experiment 5 tested the correlations between the structures in 69 schoolage children. The main findings were that children performed poorly on the comprehension of sentences containing crossing dependency coordination, in all 5 experiments, and in both languages. Their difficulty in the crossing dependency coordination was similar to their difficulty with object relatives, and their performance on crossing dependency coordination correlated with that of object-relatives. Their performance on coordination without dependency, coordination with a dependency but without crossing, and subject-relatives was good. We conclude that crossing dependencies, not only in Wh-movement dependencies, underlie the difficulty in young children’s sentence comprehension.
منابع مشابه
Comprehension of Complex Sentences in the Persian-Speaking Patients With Aphasia
Introduction: To study sentence comprehension in Persian-speaking Patients with Aphasia considering the factors of complexity. Methods: In this cross-sectional study, the performance of 6 non-fluent aphasic patients were tested and their performance was compared to 15 matched control group. Comprehension of semantically reversible sentences was assessed using a binary sentence-picture matching...
متن کاملSentence Processing Among Native vs. Nonnative Speakers: Implications for Critical Period Hypothesis
The present study intended to investigate the processing behavior of 2 groups of L2 learners of English (high and mid in proficiency) and a group of English native speakers on English active and passive reduced relative clauses. Three sets of tasks, an offline task, and 2 online tasks were conducted. Results revealed that the high-proficiency group’s performance was the same as that of the nati...
متن کاملThe emergence of relative clauses in early child language
This paper examines the development of relative clauses in early child language. It is argued that relative clauses constitute a network of related constructions that children acquire in a piecemeal bottom-up way, starting with relative clauses that are only little different from simple sentences which are gradually extended into more complex grammatical patterns. The acquisition process is dri...
متن کاملAuthor's Personal Copy the Processing of Extraposed Structures in English
In most languages, most of the syntactic dependency relations found in any given sentence are PROJECTIVE: the word–word dependencies in the sentence do not cross each other. Some syntactic dependency relations, however, are NON-PROJECTIVE: some of their word–word dependencies cross each other. Non-projective dependencies are both rarer and more computationally complex than projective dependenci...
متن کاملThe processing of extraposed structures in English.
In most languages, most of the syntactic dependency relations found in any given sentence are projective: the word-word dependencies in the sentence do not cross each other. Some syntactic dependency relations, however, are non-projective: some of their word-word dependencies cross each other. Non-projective dependencies are both rarer and more computationally complex than projective dependenci...
متن کامل